This is a piece I performed last week at Write Club at the Hideout. Two opposing ideas. Two writers. I wrote about "native." The incomparable Mary Fons wrote about "foreign." Mary won. The picture above is what I looked like. Here's what I wrote.
Imagine, if you will, that you are
a smallmouth bass
First off, you are adorable
Those golden iridescent scales cascading
down your back
That Betty Boop mouth. Sensual.
Small.
You are, and I quote a very
reputable fishing site, a “plucky game fish that gives good fight on the line”
Well
well well…
Native is what is here and what
belongs here
It is the indigenous and the natural
and the group with deepest roots
BUT
We can’t deny that in this
globalized, post-colonial age, we are, and should be a little suspicious of the
term
The word NATIVE has been used to
delegitimize the colonized (“the natives are restless”—hint: they mean DARK
people!)
The word NATIVE has been adopted by
conservative cranks to describe all those guys that they CLAIM were disenfranchised
by our most recent election results (hint: they mean WHITE people!)
So I want to take NATIVE out of the
realm of politics altogether, and wash it clean of its historical muck in the
fresh, sweet waters of that closest body of water. Lake Michigan.
Back to you, a smallmouth bass,
shimmering through the chilly damp atmosphere, maybe blowing a kiss to a drum
fish, maybe winking at a perch (or not, cause you know, no eyelids)
It’s a good life
Swimming peacefully through the
green-brown haze of the Greatest of Great Lakes, and the world, is not your
oyster, but your delicious local crayfish
When all of a sudden, it’s coming
at you, the gaping maw, a huge hole in the middle of the lake, framed by teeth
You are staring into the abyss
Then your eyes meet the eyes of
this creature
(I mean this metaphorically,
because not only do you not have eyelids, your eyes are actually on the side of
your head)
You are looking down the throat of
your own destruction
You may have heard of the
terrifying ASIAN CARP. The possible invasion of this species of hulking meaty
fish, gnashing at the water around them, their bottomless hunger, their
rapacious need to eat everything in sight sends environmentalists into a frothy
panic
They don’t belong here, the Asian
Carp
Their presence destroys the
delicate balance
They are the foreign, and they will
destroy the native
And you, the innocent little fish,
just trying to swim around
Is it your fault that
globalization, that the rapid speed at which every beast, fish or fowl can now
travel to parts of the glove where they were never meant to be means that your
very ability to gurgle and spawn should be threatened by pre-historic monsters
from Asia?
It is not.
It is our fault. The humans. We
enjoy our first world access to cheap electronics that sending boats around the
world allows. The destructive foreign influence has merely hitched a ride on
our greed. But still, the native will pay.
Now I am fully aware of the
racialized undertones to this story. Lest you fear that I espouse any sort of
xenophobic, nativist philosophy, let me assure you that I am big fan of the
human Asian-American community, having gone so far as to MARRY an
Asian-American
For you see my husband was raised
by foreigners
And let me tell you, no one loves
all things deeply, disgustingly American like a man who was a little boy with 2
heavily accented parents. He’s at home right now figuring out how to deep fry a
turkey for god’s sake.
I’m glad his parents were both
brave enough to become foreigners in a strange land. I love foreigners. We live
in a city, which seems by definition a celebration of the foreign. Cities are
the places where foreigners arrive, where they buy cheap property and open
restaurants. Where they get their footing in a new world and I am thankful for
that for both ethical and culinary reasons. But that is merely the built
environment. Nature, that thing that is native by definition, peeks through the
cracks in the pavement, the spaces between parking lots. There are places you
can stand, on the shores of Lake Michigan, within the city limits, where you
can watch the native grasses swaying, and listening to the birds who have sung
the same songs since long before you came here.
Everything I know about the native
small-mouth bass I learned from the aforementioned turkey frier, my own little
Asian Carp. He’s dragged me out to the lakefront at ungodly hours of the
morning to go fishing. Here you see Polish grandfathers, sipping their Ice
Mountain beer as the sun comes up. Vietnamese men who have arrived on bicycles,
balancing heavy buckets as they pedal. Men from places in Africa I can’t
identify, whispering rapid French to one another. They each love the lake. They
trade tips and disagree about which of the native species is the tastiest. And
if you walk past them on an early morn, you’ll see them periodically pull a
fish from the Lake frown at it, and throw it behind them to be fed to the
seagulls. Foreign, invasive species. These foreigners share one thing, a love
of the native.